The Washington Street Mall clock at dusk in Cape May

Experiences

Dining

Long dinners in Cape May, seafood by the water and boardwalk classics.

Cape May · The Wildwoods

The local guide

These are the places we go ourselves, from long dinners in Cape May to takeout on the docks. Some are BYOB, some are seasonal, and every one is worth the trip.

Date night in Cape May

The Ebbitt Room at the Virginia Hotel cooks with ingredients from Beach Plum Farm and serves nightly prix fixe menus in an elegant Victorian dining room. Tisha's on the Washington Street Mall is a long-running Cape May classic with Italian-influenced seafood, and it is BYOB. For a special family dinner, Primal on Beach Avenue does high-end steak and fish. Order the New Zealand lobster, and book ahead on Resy.

On the water

The Lobster House on Fisherman's Wharf has been a Cape May staple for generations. Our local tip: grab takeout and eat by the schooner for the breeze. Lucky Bones near the harbor has brick-oven pizza, fried oysters and local beers, and it is just as good in the winter. Port Marina on Cape May Harbor feels like the Hamptons meets Cape May, with sushi, fresh seafood and DJs. It sits outside town on the way to Wildwood Crest, so plan to drive.

Sand between your toes

The Rusty Nail serves breakfast, lunch and dinner within sight of the ocean. Head to the sand, grab a spot by a fire pit and bring beach toys for the kids. Some of our favorite bartenders on the island work here. Taco Caballito on Beach Avenue pairs creative tacos with great margaritas and open windows at happy hour. Harry's Ocean Bar has the best live music in Cape May and an orange crush on the roof deck that is hard to beat. Carney's is family-owned, open late in season and the place to dance with friends, now with a fresh coastal renovation.

Sunsets and farm dinners

Fish House near Sunset Beach is small and polished, and best at golden hour with a glass of rosé. Stay for the sunset and the evening flag ceremony. Beach Plum Farm in West Cape May hosts dinners and brunch on the farm itself. Walk out back to see the pigs and feed the chickens.

Coffee and casual

The Blue Pig inside Congress Hall has vintage coastal charm and great iced coffee. In the winter we often work from The Brown Room at Congress Hall, next to the fireplace. Ostara's and Golden Stop in West Cape May are our coffee and breakfast stops, and Secondo has a chicken parm and an old fashioned we keep going back for.

North Cape May

5 West Pub is our North Cape May staple, from the same owners as Tisha's. Order the dirty shrimp and the calamari.

The Wildwoods

On the boardwalk, dinner and dessert are one walk: Sam's Pizza Palace, Curley's Fries with malt vinegar and water ice from John's. For a sit-down dinner with a view, Urie's Waterfront has been on the Wildwood Yacht Basin since 1956.

Good to know

Before you go.

Summer weekends book up fast in Cape May, so reserve ahead. Many of our favorites are BYOB. Some spots close or cut hours in the off-season, so check before you go.

Find a stay